Analysing Buy vs Rent For Residential Properties : Impact on Property Prices
By hope, Section Gurgaon Real Estate Property Posted on Sat Oct 29, 2005 at 09:11:34 PM EST
I stay in Gurgaon and some weeks back I decided to look for a property for purchase in one of the prominent building in DLF phase - II under pressure from Family. The going price quoted to me was about Rs 90 lacs which meant that after paying stamp duty and some basic expenditure on the House (like woodwork) it would have cost me atleast 100 lacs to make it liveable. Looking at the property rate, I started thinking does it really make sense to buy a property at such high prices today or does it make sense to rent the same out. The rental charges at which the properties dealers were willing to rent out were between 25,000-30,000/month (different than they quote in newspapers).
So I started doing a little calculation as follows:
If I decide to buy a property on loan (assuming I don't have stash of money floating round with no avenues to invest), my expected opportunity cost would be as follows:
Buy The Flat
Cost of the Property : Rs 100 lacs
Opportunity Cost @9% per annum : Rs 9 lacs per annum
based on current average lending rates
Add : Maintenance charges @ 3000/month : Rs 0.36 lacs
Less : tax rebate on Interest payment : Rs 0.50 lacs
(33% of 1.50 lacs)
Total Opportunity Cost : Rs 8.86 lacs
Rent the Flat
Month Rent of the property " Rs 30,000 per month
Total Rental Cost :Rs 3.6 lacs per annum
Net Savings per annum in : Rs 5.26 lacs
Renting vs Ownership
Some assumptions have been made like there is no tax rebate on rental available to the person which would have made the situation more favourable for renting. Also some figures are rounded off to convey the basic message.
I was shocked to see the potential saving every year I can make, if I decide to postpone the decision to buy the property for one year. The critics of the analysis will say that the properties is not purchased for Rentals but also for the future price rise.
So I decided to do a one more analysis of WHATIF the property prices were to rise by 10% in one year and whatif it was to fall by 10% in one year, before I decide to take the decision to BUY the property after year one.
1. Price Rise of 10% in one year - If I decide to buy the property after one year and the price has gone up by 10%, I would have lost ( 10% of 100 lacs less 5.26 lacs of savings in Rent vs Buy in year 1) - Rs 4.74 lacs only.
2. However if the prices were to fall by 10% in one year, I would have stand to gain (10% of 100 lacs +5.26 lacs in savings) or Rs 15.26 lacs. That is very healthy potential gain for a salaried person.
There are two variables now:
1. Some may argue that the rentals will go up substantially over one year. However given the occupancy rates of the inhabited buildings currently and expected supply of new houses in one year, it is anyone's guess that whether it will go up as much to bridge the gap. Rentals in my place have actually remained stable or come down by 5-10% in last 3-6 months.
2. Then there is a debate about whether the prices will go up in one year or in near future in general. I leave that to the readers to decide that what is the probability of the prices going up by 10% vs its falling by 10% in one year given the following broad parameters
a. Oversupply of houses
b. Very low actual usage by owners. More than 70% of properties is held for investment.
c. Famous infrastructure of Gurgaon (!!!), I don't even want to talk about it.
d. Rising interest rates for housing loans and increasing reluctance of the banks to finance high priced properties without adequate margins.
Historically, we have seen that rental yields on Residential properties tends to remain stable within a range of 4.5-5% of the property price as compared to about 3.25-3.5% (post maintenance charges) today in Gurgaon. This calls for a strong correction in the coming year with upward movement in Property Rentals or Reduction in property prices or both. What will be the expected trend, I have my own views and you can make your own.
I am happy to get into a debate with other learned people on an alternate analysis of the situation. Let me warn that the analysis is from the perspective of a buyer for actual usage and someone has said that this is the community which sustains the price in the end.
 |
|
 |
 |
Login
Membership has its privileges. Choose a username and provide a working email - that's all it takes to join. Click below to make a new account.
Make a new account
Who's Online? (53)
. Unregistered Visitors (53)
Note: You may cloak yourself from appearing here in your Display Preferences.
Front Page
Sunday March 14th
. Haryana To Invest Over Rs.1,200 Crore In Industrial Land (0 comments)
. Unauthorized Construction Market Fall By Demolition Squad (0 comments)
. India's Real Estate Boom Is on Shaky Ground (0 comments)
. Beverly Park I Apartments Struggle To Get The Title of The Land (0 comments)
. Circle Rates May Rise By 20% Of Property In Noida (0 comments)
. Affordability Extended: Noida Extension Is All Set To Become Delhi NCR's Next Budget Housing Hub (0 comments)
. Attention Property Owners/Tax Payers! MCD Offers Special Amnesty Cum Tax Settlement Scheme (0 comments)
Saturday March 13th
. The 8-lane Noida-Gt. Noida E' way Promises To Give Two Potential Locations A Realty Boost (0 comments)
. "Great Time to Buy" (Famous Last Words) As Real Estate Brokers Always Say (1 comments)
. Role Reversal: Ghaziabad Police Lets People Take Charge: Residents Get To Play `Police-Police' (7 comments)
. Limited Mining: Haryana Submits Aravalli Rehab Plan Before SC (0 comments)
. Property Prices Prepare To Dole Out More For Homes (0 comments)
. Verify Your Servant, Or Pay Rs 5,000 Fine (0 comments)
Friday March 12th
. Grand Plan: Integrate All Transport In Delhi, NCR (0 comments)
. At Last: Help For E'Way Pedestrians, 5 New Underpasses Planned (0 comments)
. Delhi Best City To Live In (0 comments)
Thursday March 11th
. Haryana sees Record 70% Investment In Development (0 comments)
. Haryana Proposes To Set Up Migrants Resource Centre (0 comments)
. Haryana To Announce Its New Industrial Policy by April (0 comments)
. Municipal Corporation of Gurgaon Issues Public Notice Regarding Assessment of House Tax in Gurgaon (0 comments)
. Now, Shop Till You Drop In Gurgaon (0 comments)
. Greater Noida- Noida Expressway In Toll Mode (0 comments)
. Is Emaar MGF Palm Hills Sector 77 Residential Project a Good Investment? (23 comments)
. Insurance For Parents Of Special Children Soon (0 comments)
. Consumer Fora Can Handle Arbitrations (0 comments)
. New Law Against Touts In Pipeline (0 comments)
. Government Scraps 12 Special Economic Zones (0 comments)
. Base Rate To Bring In Transparency In Loan Pricing: RBI (1 comments)
Wednesday March 10th
. Haryana Set To Join Hands With Private Firms To Develop NCR (0 comments)
. Facelift Of Faridabad's Biggest Nullah Planned (0 comments)
. IT Exports From Haryana Touch Rs 21,000 cr , Report Projects 12 pc Growth In Current Fiscal (0 comments)
. Supertech To Invest Rs 4,000 cr in 15 Projects; Plans IPO (0 comments)
. Realty Major BPTP Plans Rs 1,500 cr IPO In Early FY11 (0 comments)
. Delhi's 3-D Map Ready, Govt Depts To Begin Use From April 1 (0 comments)
. Staff Hired For Udyog Vihar To Address Security, Parking Woes (0 comments)
. IPO-Bound Realtors Sitting On Fence Despite Sebi Nod (0 comments)
. Overseas Realty Funds Struggle, Shut Shop Or Put Plans On Hold (0 comments)
. Real Estate Fund Flow Under Watch (0 comments)
Tuesday March 9th
. DLF May Miss Residential Sales Goal (0 comments)
. New Draft Policy On Affordable Housing In Rural Areas (0 comments)
. DLF Says Price Hikes Are Inevitable (0 comments)
. Realtors To Assess Impact Of Service Tax On Housing Complexes (0 comments)
. Gulshan Homz Betting Strategically On Affordable Homes (0 comments)
Sunday March 7th
. Honda Picks R'sthan Over Haryana For Second Unit (2 comments)
. First No-Frills Airport To Come Up Near Jaipur (0 comments)
Saturday March 6th
. We Bring Good News - Expect Jobs & Hikes (0 comments)
. Residential Rentals Exempt From Service Tax (0 comments)
. Look Beyond Gurgaon, Industry Told (1 comments)
. RBI Panel Proposes Collateral-Free Loans (0 comments)
. Stress Relief :Banks Can Lend Below Base Rate, System To Come Into Effect From July 1 (0 comments)
Older Stories...
|
|