Click Here to See Large Map of QuBREX Property listings
Home | Ask Questions | Computer Gupshup | Free Member Diaries | Contact Us - Sanjay @ 98 712 19911

When Is Salary of Non Resident Based in USA Not Taxable In India?


By djain128, Section Ask Questions
Posted on Mon Apr 27, 2009 at 04:39:22 AM EST


Q I'm Indian Citizen, & US Green Card holder. Working in USA from Nov 1999 till now. Working for bigger telecommunication company and they have office in India & USA. I took a project in 2005 and required frequent business travel to India. I was travelling during 2005 & 2006 5 to 7 times and have spent around 180 days on each year. But none of my stay was more than 30 days and all are for business trips. I'm getting my salary in US. Do I still have to file Income tax in India?

by junk_1208@yahoo.com

Ans Since you are Indian citizen and you did not stay for more than 181 days in a year , you saved yourself from being treated as Resident. If that would have been the case, all income of yours whether earned in India or USA would have been taxable in India. However, since you are Non Resident as per Income tax Act, your income is taxable in India if

   1. Any income is received in India
   2. Any income is deemed to be received in India
   3. Any income which accrues or arises in India
   4. Any Income which is deemed to accrue or arise in India[section 9(1)(vi)]

Since you are paid salary by USA based company and received your salary in USA , conditions 1,2,3 above are not satisfied.

As far as the last condition is concerned, there is specific provision for salary under section 9(1)(ii) which states that salary is deemed to accrue or arise in India "if it is earned in India." There is an explanation which declares that " income of the nature referred to in this clause payable for service rendered in India shall be regarded as income earned in India .This is a grey area and only judicial interpretation can clear the ambiguities . Plain reading of the Act shows that for the service rendered by you in India fro which you received salary should be treated as income earned in India and therefore even if you are non resident , same is taxable in India.So, prima facie' , your salary seems to taxable under I T Act.

The saving Grace!
However, there is Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement between India and USA which contains Article 16 related to dependent personal services which states that except in following condition the salaries ,wages or remuneration is taxable in the State where the employment is exercised . The conditions are given sub clause 2 of article 16 which is reproduced below :

    2. Notwithstanding the provisions of paragraph 1, remuneration derived by a resident of a Contracting State in respect of an employment exercised in the other Contracting State shall be taxable only in the first-mentioned State, if :
    (a) the recipient is present in the other State for a period or periods not exceeding in the aggregate 183 days in the relevant taxable year ;
    (b) the remuneration is paid by, or on behalf of, an employer who is not a resident of the other State ; and
    (c) the remuneration is not borne by a permanent establishment or a fixed base or a trade or business which the employer has in the other State"

I find from the facts narrated by you , conditions 2(a) and 2(b) is definitely satisfied as you were not in India for more than 180 days in any one financial year and remuneration is paid by your employer which is not a resident of India. The third condition , you will have to check ,if your salary was borne by the permanent establishment (subsidiary) of your company in India . If Indian office of your company did not bear the salary paid to you , then DTAA protects you from being taxed in India. You should also be aware that it is legally settled that DTAA supersede I.T Act . For more on this read this article.

Therefore , there is no need to file the return of income since your salary received in USA from MNC based in USA is not taxable in India by virtue of Article 16(2) of the DTAA signed between two countries.

< Public Notice On Sugar Stocks Held By Dealers - Government Of National Capital Territory Of Delhi | When & How A Power Of Attorney Should Be Used >

Related Links

. USA
. Also by djain128
Win A Jeans Twice a Week
&
Win A Kurta 7 Days A Week

Login

Membership has its privileges. Choose a username and provide a working email - that's all it takes to join. Click below to make a new account.
Make a new account

Username:
Password:
Bangkok
BIHARSCOOP.COM
JEWELRYFRIEND.com

Who's Online? (57)

. Unregistered Visitors (57)

Note: You may cloak yourself from appearing here in your Display Preferences.

Recent Comments

. Banks (WalkerR)

. Fool's Decision (Pradeep)

. Constructive input! (rigby2015)

. I am Sick (Pradeep)

. Chor Sipai (Pradeep)

. tiles or marble flooring? (bitseee)

. Case againt Raheja Builder in State Commission (Gaurav Mehta)

. Smoke Around you!!! (luckyindialucky)

. Not Rental..total return is less than 1% (luckyindialucky)

. So u are IDIOT without any doubt. (luckyindialucky)

Recent Member Diaries

PAYING GUEST ACCOMODATION AVAILABLE
by Freeman - November 14
62 comments


Paying Guest Accomodation for Girls in Sushant Lok
by poonam23 - November 13
38 comments


Skoda Amb 2002 VIP Number for sale
by phugatboy - November 13
5 comments


Unitech's Strategy for coming years
by malikboss - November 2
37 comments


Is there a blind home in Gurgaon?
by SGARG - October 30
8 comments


Traffic Jams on the Roads
by Pradeep - October 16
13 comments


SANTRO XING FOR SALE
by satishcmishra - October 15

Breeding nurseries of mosquitos for DLF city
by RAJKUMAR77 - October 11
1 comment


PREVENTIONS IN THE SEASON OF DENGUE
by sumandua - October 11

KLJ TOWN PLANNERS PVT LTD
by nd - October 4
28 comments



More Diaries...

Front Page

Sunday March 14th
. Haryana To Invest Over Rs.1,200 Crore In Industrial Land (0 comments)
. Unauthorized Construction Market Fall By Demolition Squad (0 comments)
. India's Real Estate Boom Is on Shaky Ground (0 comments)
. Beverly Park I Apartments Struggle To Get The Title of The Land (0 comments)
. Circle Rates May Rise By 20% Of Property In Noida (0 comments)
. Affordability Extended: Noida Extension Is All Set To Become Delhi NCR's Next Budget Housing Hub (0 comments)
. Attention Property Owners/Tax Payers! MCD Offers Special Amnesty Cum Tax Settlement Scheme (0 comments)

Saturday March 13th
. The 8-lane Noida-Gt. Noida E' way Promises To Give Two Potential Locations A Realty Boost (0 comments)
. "Great Time to Buy" (Famous Last Words) As Real Estate Brokers Always Say (1 comments)
. Role Reversal: Ghaziabad Police Lets People Take Charge: Residents Get To Play `Police-Police' (5 comments)
. Limited Mining: Haryana Submits Aravalli Rehab Plan Before SC (0 comments)
. Property Prices Prepare To Dole Out More For Homes (0 comments)
. Verify Your Servant, Or Pay Rs 5,000 Fine (0 comments)

Friday March 12th
. Grand Plan: Integrate All Transport In Delhi, NCR (0 comments)
. At Last: Help For E'Way Pedestrians, 5 New Underpasses Planned (0 comments)
. Delhi Best City To Live In (0 comments)

Thursday March 11th
. Haryana sees Record 70% Investment In Development (0 comments)
. Haryana Proposes To Set Up Migrants Resource Centre (0 comments)
. Haryana To Announce Its New Industrial Policy by April (0 comments)
. Municipal Corporation of Gurgaon Issues Public Notice Regarding Assessment of House Tax in Gurgaon (0 comments)
. Now, Shop Till You Drop In Gurgaon (0 comments)
. Greater Noida- Noida Expressway In Toll Mode (0 comments)
. Is Emaar MGF Palm Hills Sector 77 Residential Project a Good Investment? (14 comments)
. Insurance For Parents Of Special Children Soon (0 comments)
. Consumer Fora Can Handle Arbitrations (0 comments)
. New Law Against Touts In Pipeline (0 comments)
. Government Scraps 12 Special Economic Zones (0 comments)
. Base Rate To Bring In Transparency In Loan Pricing: RBI (1 comments)

Wednesday March 10th
. Haryana Set To Join Hands With Private Firms To Develop NCR (0 comments)
. Facelift Of Faridabad's Biggest Nullah Planned (0 comments)
. IT Exports From Haryana Touch Rs 21,000 cr , Report Projects 12 pc Growth In Current Fiscal (0 comments)
. Supertech To Invest Rs 4,000 cr in 15 Projects; Plans IPO (0 comments)
. Realty Major BPTP Plans Rs 1,500 cr IPO In Early FY11 (0 comments)
. Delhi's 3-D Map Ready, Govt Depts To Begin Use From April 1 (0 comments)
. Staff Hired For Udyog Vihar To Address Security, Parking Woes (0 comments)
. IPO-Bound Realtors Sitting On Fence Despite Sebi Nod (0 comments)
. Overseas Realty Funds Struggle, Shut Shop Or Put Plans On Hold (0 comments)
. Real Estate Fund Flow Under Watch (0 comments)

Tuesday March 9th
. DLF May Miss Residential Sales Goal (0 comments)
. New Draft Policy On Affordable Housing In Rural Areas (0 comments)
. DLF Says Price Hikes Are Inevitable (0 comments)
. Realtors To Assess Impact Of Service Tax On Housing Complexes (0 comments)
. Gulshan Homz Betting Strategically On Affordable Homes (0 comments)

Sunday March 7th
. Honda Picks R'sthan Over Haryana For Second Unit (2 comments)
. First No-Frills Airport To Come Up Near Jaipur (0 comments)

Saturday March 6th
. We Bring Good News - Expect Jobs & Hikes (0 comments)
. Residential Rentals Exempt From Service Tax (0 comments)
. Look Beyond Gurgaon, Industry Told (1 comments)
. RBI Panel Proposes Collateral-Free Loans (0 comments)
. Stress Relief :Banks Can Lend Below Base Rate, System To Come Into Effect From July 1 (0 comments)

Older Stories...


All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective companies. Comments are owned by the Poster. The Rest (c) GurgaonSCOOP.com and QBTPL.
Home | Ask Questions | Computer Gupshup | Free Member Diaries | Contact Us - Sanjay @ 98 712 19911